|
NEWS LINKS
(below)
▼
Important ruling from Oregon Supreme Court, November 2012 that throws out the
Manson-type approach to eyewitness identification evidence ...
New article in American Prospect Magazine on eyewitness
identification December 2012
Article in Discover
Magazine on Eyewitness
Identification, November 2012
American Bar Association
Journal article on eyewitness identification May 2012
New
York Times August 28 article on lineups
Listen to NPR story on eyewitness identification
Eyewitness IDs can be made better; Miller McCune news article
Mandatory minimums for lineups...
Florida Innocence Commission Probes Mistaken Identifications

Wells on 60 Minutes
NEW! "My search as a cop for justice in a flawed criminal justice system"
by Sunil Dutta
Story out of Dallas: Witness describes how prosecutor told him
which guy to identify. [I have been writing about these
problems for over 30 years. These real case discoveries are becoming more
commonplace but the reforms that I have been proposing are still being resisted
in many jurisdictions across the U.S....]
Boston DA Conley credits double-blind lineup reforms in part for higher
conviction rate.
"New approach has
convinced jurors that police are more careful about whom they arrest" he said.
Associated Press article Sept, 25, 2009 on New Jersey lineups case
USA Today article on lineups Sept. 19, 2009
Who killed the eyewitness bill in Texas?
Newsweek article on eyewitness identification
(March 2009)
Reason article on
eyewitness identification April 8, 2009
Georgia law
enforcement agrees to eyewitness identification changes...
See
Atlanta Constitution article
"During Williams’s trial, the victim
was asked, on a scale of one to a hundred, how sure
she was that Williams assaulted her." “One hundred
and twenty,” she testified. Williams served 21 years
in prison before DNA tests cleared him.
Dallas Police Department revamps show-up policy
Justice Project survey shows that only a small percentage of Texas police
departments have written eyewitness identification policies and those that do
are generally inadequate...
Three Dallas Morning News articles on eyewitness identification-
October 12 article,
Oct. 13 article,
Oct. 16 article
May 2008 article in Nature on
eyewitness identification research.
JEHT
Foundation funds eyewitness identification field experiments
208th DNA exoneration is mistaken ID in Florida
Georgia House approves eyewitness legislation in 2008
Atlanta
Progressive News See also earlier articles:
Atlanta Constitution
Atlanta Progressive News
North Carolina
adopts lineup reforms
Justice Project review of eyewitness identification policy
Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette story on composites from March 25, 2007
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
eyewitness story March 12, 2007
New Jersey Supreme
Court ruling requires eyewitness ID behavior to be recorded. See Star Ledger
article August 1, 2006
Associated
Press story on mistaken identification from July 31, 2006
Wrong
man executed because of mistaken ID?
Also,
see video here
Governing
Magazine article on eyewitness reform May 2006
Eyewitness recommendations
of the California Commission for the Fair Administration of Justice
True Witness
Download
Wisconsin's new Model Policy for Eyewitness Identification
Was
an innocent man executed in Texas based on eyewitness identification? You
decide.
U.S. Court of Appeals 7th
Circuit upholds Wells' testimony in civil suit regarding Chicago
lineup
Wisconsin court
rules on show-ups
A July 2005 ruling by the Wisconsin Supreme Court on show-ups.
Click here for the written opinion
Miami Herald
article from August 2005 on lineup reforms
Virginia
to revamp lineup procedures, story from the Washington Post
Listen to Feb 2005 NPR story
on lineups
Read Chicago Tribune
story on lineups from February 17, 2005.
Read story from February 7,
2005 Chicago Tribune on lineups
Jury
finds FBI framed man in part via eyewitness evidence; January 2005 article
January
5, 2005 article on eyewitness identification from Legal Affairs
Dec. 8, 2004 Christian Science
Monitor article on lineups
Police charge man
based on witness identification from photo lineup. But he was dead a year
before crime occurred: Associated Press story
Boston Globe
article click here Boston Herald
article click here
North Carolina law enforcement
moving towards double-blind sequential lineups. Article from Durham, NC
News
and Observer, June 2004.
Scientific American
article on lineups, click here
Click to read (April 2003) eyewitness
identification article from The Washington Post
Click to read (April 2003)
eyewitness identification article from The Economist
Click to read
(April 2003) eyewitness identification article from The St. Petersburg
Times
Read
Newsday
article on lineups from February 12, 2003, click here
|
From
this link you can download several of my published articles.
New
publication by Wells & Loftus (2013) on witness memory
Forensic Science Testing: The Forensic-Filler Control Method for Controlling
Contextual Bias, Etimating Error Rates, and Calibrating Analysts' Reports.
Article accepted for publication in the Journal of Applied Research in Memory
and Cognition. (by Wells, Wilford, & Smalarz, 2013)
New articles in press (in Perspectives on Psychological
Science) addressing Clark's argument that reforms such as the double-blind
lineup, unbiased instructions, and so on can reduce "hit rates". The
counterargument is that these "hit rates" that he is concerned aobut are not
true hits at all but instead were suggestiveness-induced responses and actually
represent ill-gotten gains ...
Wells at al article link
Newman & Loftus article
link
Materials from Smalarz & Wells post-identification feedback/testimony 2012
study (1)
screenshots and lineup
(2) testimony script
questions
September 19, 2011
Field experiment with actual eyewitnesses shows sequential
reduces filler identifications without reducing identifications of the
suspect..
Meet the
double-blind lineup: Notes on the double-blind lineup. What is it?
Where did it come from? What is its purpose?. Who is using it?
Charman and
Wells (2011) article shows that "duds" in a lineup increase eyewitnesses'
certainty in mistaken identifications
NEW New Jersey Supreme Court issues
major ruling on eyewitness identification August 24, 2011
2011 chapter by Wells and Penrod on research methods in
eyewitness identification research
New
research shows fundamental difference between how faces versus other objects are
processed (Wilford and Wells, 2010, Psychological Science)
New
meta-analysis of the simultaneous versus sequential lineup (2011,
Psychology, Public Policy, and Law) "...8% fewer
accurate identifications but 22% fewer mistaken identifications with sequential.
An identification from a sequential is more likely to be accurate..."
Figure 4
Suggestive
Eyewitness Identification Procedures: Why the U.S. Supreme Court Needs to
Revisit Manson v. Braithwaite (2009 article published in Law and Human
Behavior)
7th Circuit upholds Wells'
testimony
A short Q&A with Wells:
http://www.livescience.com/culture/eyewitness-identification-wells-sl-100519.html
More on the Illinois Pilot Project:
(1) The Evanston site gave up its raw data and
Nancy Steblay's analysis reveals that assignment of cases was biased against the
double-blind sequential. READ THIS ARTICLE
(2) Wells article argues that "...it would
never be acceptable to test one procedure (e.g., sequential) that used
double-blind techniques and compare the results to another procedure (e.g,
simultaneous) that used non-blind techniques."
READ THIS
ARTICLE
The Duke Lacrosse rape case: How not to do a lineup -- A chapter
by Wells, Cutler, and Hasel
What if two
witnesses identify the same person? What if one identifies the person and
another identifies someone else? Article by Clark and Wells on
multiple-witness identifications (Law and Human Behavior)
NEW: The
Misidentification of John White
The Duke University lacrosse rape case: Chapter by Wells, Cutler & Hasel,
2009
Article on eyewitnesses
published in Psychological Science in the Public Interest
Have a video viewer?
Click
here to take the Wells eyewitness test
National
Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers files lawsuit to obtain data from
departments that participated in Chicago lineups study (February 8, 2006)
Here
is the Mecklenburg Report on the study of lineups in Illinois.
Here are
my comments on the Mecklenburg Report [Updated May 2006]
Wisconsin
Attorney General stays with lineup reforms, rejects relevance of Illinois
study.
Here
are Nancy Steblay's observations on the data and interpretations in the
Mecklenburg Report.
Two new articles, both in press in
Law and Human
Behavior.
1. Does
morphing composite faces produce a better likeness of the culprit than
the individual composites?
Stimuli from Hasel and Wells
morphing study
2. Does
the appearance change instruction improve eyewitnesses' lineup performance?
Appearance-change
clips from Charman & Wells experiment
Link to National Science Foundation site describing some of Wells' work
CHAMPION
readers: Click here to download the article that I mentioned in the Champion
article
Fascinating new (2005) book by James
Doyle titled True Witness: Cops, Courts, Science, and the Battle
Against Misidentification. Click here for commentary and ordering
information.
New
experiments show that having eyewitnesses build face composites can damage
their ability to make an identification from a lineup. Click here to read
manuscript
Memory
for People and Events chapter by Wells & Loftus (2003) click here
Article published in Annual Review
of Psychology (2003) on eyewitness identification by Wells and Olson, click
here to download
Did Scott Peterson
murder his wife? What is the evidentiary value of an extra-marital affair?
(article by Wells)
New article in press
in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied. The
article concerns the question of how the speed with which eyewitnesses
make their identifications relates to the accuracy of the identifications...
The
Psychology of Alibis: A taxonomy. This article was
published recently in Law and Human Behavior. Click here to view
Article on
the distorting effects of feedback on eyewitnesses (Wells, Olson, &
Charman, 2003) published in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
Article
on best practices in constructing and conducting lineups, click here
Click here to download a PDF
version of the Wells & Olson "Information Gain" article published in
Journal
of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2002.
2002 article reports
experiment showing lineup feedback harms accuracy-confidence relation (Bradfield,
Wells, & Olson, Journal of Applied Psychology) View article
here
From
the Lab to the Police Station: This is an article published in American
Psychologist regarding the role of psychology in developing guidelines
for eyewitness evidence.
What is wrong with the Manson v. Braithwaite
(1977) test of eyewitness identification evidence? Plenty.
Ken Patanaude,
of the Northampton, MA Police Department just published this article regarding
their adoption of double-blind, sequential lineups.
Prestigous North Carolina Commission makes recommendations
to change lineup procedures!
Story
1 Story 2
The National Institute of Justice has now released its eyewitness
training manual for law enforcement. I co-chaired the identification
section. The Manual is not perfect, and it represented a compromise, but
this manual can be quite useful for police trainers. Use this address to
view and download: http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/nij/eyewitness/188678.html
NEW!
Minnesota departments try new lineup procedures
June 2003
Wall Street Journal story, click here
Have a video viewer?
Click
here to take the Wells eyewitness test
No video viewer? take this one instead click
here
Click HERE
to download the Department of Justice Guide for the Collection and Preservation
of Eyewitness Evidence
Drivers'
licenses being used to construct photo lineups; click here
|

click
for additional photos
For a recent version of my
curriculum vita click
here.
NEW
Wells
appointed as the Wendy and Mark Stavish Chair in Social Sciences
Wells receives Honorary
Doctorate from John Jay College of Criminal Justice (May 2008)
For a short
biographical sketch,
click here Gary L. Wells is Distinguished Professor of Psychology
and the Wendy and Mark Stavish Chair in Social Sciences at Iowa State University 
and the Director of Social
Sciences of the Institute of Forensic Science
and Public Policy* (*an institute of the American Judicature Society)
http://www.ajs.org/
Gary L. Wells is past President of the American
Psychology-Law Society
Jen
face
composite of Wells
click
for humorous image
Gary L. Wells, Ph.D.
Professor of Psychology
Distinguished Professor
of Liberal Arts and Sciences
E-mail Gary Wells
Mailing address:
Psychology Department
Iowa State University
Ames, IA 50011
phone: 515-294-6033
fax: 515-294-6424
Click here to read an article on
eyewitness identification from the New Yorker magazine January 8, 2001
Click
here to view video from CBS News on Eyewitness Identification Procedures
Click
here to read an article on eyewitness expert testimony from the August
10, 2001 Wall Street Journal
After reading the Wall Street Journal
article, click here to read my comments.
An article
from the Chronicle of Higher Education on eyewitness reseaerch.
New Jersey Adopts Sequential and Blind Testing With Lineups! Read
this article from July 21 NEW YORK TIMES
Read New Jersey Guidelines
and cover letter from Attorney General Farmer here
Here
is an editorial on the New Jersey Guidelines
Click
here to view a video that discusses problems with eyewitness identification.
It takes a few minutes to load, but it is worth it
Does
the sequential lineup reduce accurate identifications in addition to reducing
mistaken identifications? Yes, but...(click here)
UK police hold dog lineup!
An analysis of the 100+
DNA exoneration cases click here
Click
here to see the Illinois Governor's Commission Recommendations for lineups
(they begin with recommendation 10). These are worth reading.
Eyewitness Expert testimony
rulings in selected states, click here
NEW Texas
judge sees merit in proposed lineup reforms; click here
Click
here to read a 30 May, 2002 article from the Christian Science Monitor
on lineups.
NEW: Atlantic
Monthly article by Margaret Talbot calls for sequential lineups and blind
testing. Click here
Frequently asked questions about eyewitness
identification
|